People got bent out of shape over the unrealism of SSP585, but seem happy with equally unlikely scenarios if they project massive negative emissions.
Scenarios have multiple purposes. One purpose is to say what would happen if emissions were much higher or much lower than anticipated. Scenarios should therefore bracket expectations. If we do not have unrealistic scenarios, the suite of scenarios are not doing their job.
People got bent out of shape over the unrealism of SSP585, but seem happy with equally unlikely scenarios if they project massive negative emissions.
Scenarios have multiple purposes. One purpose is to say what would happen if emissions were much higher or much lower than anticipated. Scenarios should therefore bracket expectations. If we do not have unrealistic scenarios, the suite of scenarios are not doing their job.
Predictions are hard, especially about the future. Sets of scenarios should stretch, but not break, credibility at both the high and the low end.